Borders

Last week, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) released a revised Directive governing searches of electronic devices at the border.  These are the first official revisions CBP has made to its guidelines and procedures for devices since its 2009 Directive.  The new Directive is intended to reflect the evolution of technology over the intervening decade, and CBP’s corresponding need to update its investigative techniques.

Notably (and as in previous CBP Directives), the new Directive does not require officials to obtain a warrant before conducting searches of travelers’ devices—even if the traveler being searched is an American—based on CBP’s position that searches and seizures at the border are exempt from the Fourth Amendment’s “probable cause” requirement.  CBP nevertheless acknowledges that its searches must still meet the Fourth Amendment’s “reasonableness” requirement, which the self-imposed restrictions contained in the Directive are meant to achieve. 
Continue Reading CBP Revises Rules for Border Searches of Electronic Devices

Last week, dating website PlentyOfFish withdrew its offer to buy bankrupt rival True.com, citing concerns raised by Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott that the sale would violate True.com’s privacy policy and expose its members to unexpected privacy risks.  Two weeks ago, Abbott filed an objection in U.S. Bankruptcy Court to block the proposed transfer of True.com’s membership database, which contains personal information about the website’s 43 million subscribers.  True.com has been in Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings since 2012.

The Texas Attorney General objected to the proposed sale on the grounds that that it was inconsistent with True.com’s privacy policy, which Abbott argued “contains ambiguities as to whether Customers will have a right to opt-out or opt-in to consent to the transfer of their [personal information].”  As part of the bankruptcy proceeding, True.com had entered into an Asset Purchase Agreement with PlentyOfFish, another popular dating website, under which PlentyOfFish would gain access to True.com’s extensive database of members’ personal information.  But last week, PlentyOfFish withdrew from the Asset Purchase Agreement, citing the Texas Attorney General’s objection.  In a letter filed with the court on October 23, PlentyOfFish stated that the transfer of True.com’s customer information “do[es] not appear to be legal, valid and effective,” and that the sale “appears to violate Seller’s privacy policy which affects and binds Seller’s assets.”  Markus Frind, the CEO and founder of PlentyOfFish, addressed the problem candidly in his blog, asking “Who in their right mind is going to buy a dating site with 43 million members if you are not allowed access to those members?” Continue Reading Texas AG Objections To Transfer of Personal Data Demonstrate Significance of Privacy Policy Disclosures