China

On March 15, 2019, the State Administration for Market Regulation and the Cyberspace Administration of China (“CAC”) jointly issued the Announcement on the Implementation of App Security Certification (the “Announcement”), creating a voluntary (but state-sanctioned) security certification scheme for mobile applications (“Security Certification Scheme”).

Operators of mobile applications are encouraged to obtain this certification to demonstrate their compliance with China’s national standard, GB/T 35273 Information Security Technology — Personal Information Security Specification (“the Standard”), in terms of their collection and use of personal data (our previous blogpost about the Standard can be found here).  Search engines and mobile application stores are encouraged to recommend certified applications to users.

The Implementation Rules on Security Certification of Mobile Internet Application (“Implementing Rules”), which set out detailed procedural requirements for the Security Certification Scheme, were also released at the same time as an annex to the Announcement.

Although not mandatory, as the state-sanctioned certification scheme for personal information protection, the creation of this program illustrates the Chinese regulators’ willingness to use soft tools to encourage best practices in the marketplace.
Continue Reading China Introduces Mobile Application Security Certification Scheme

On February 1, 2019, China’s National Information Security Standardization Technical Committee (“TC260”) released a set of amendments to GB/T 35273-2017 Information Technology – Personal Information Security Specification (“the Standard”) for public comment.  The comment period ends on March 3.

Although not legally binding, the Standard has been highly influential since becoming effective in May 2018, as it set out the best practices expected by Chinese regulators (see our previous blogpost on the Standard here).  The Standard has been widely used by companies to benchmark their compliance efforts in China.

The draft amendments reflect Chinese regulators’ evolved thinking on a number of important topics that are hotly debated around the world, such as enhanced notice and consent requirements and requirements for target advertising.  The draft amendments would also introduce new requirements for third party access to data and revise notification requirements for data beaches, among other proposed changes.
Continue Reading China Releases Draft Amendments to the Personal Information Protection Standard

Mobile phone manufacturer BLU Products, Inc. entered into a settlement agreement with the FTC last week to resolve allegations that one of BLU’s China-based vendors collected personal information about its consumers without proper consent.

The settlement agreement, which took the form of a consent order, applies not only to BLU but also to its CEO and any other companies he owns and controls.  It requires that the company clarify its disclosures regarding customer data use and protection. It also requires BLU to implement a new data security program. In the new security program, BLU must address security risks related to the development and management of new and existing covered devices and must better protect the security, confidentiality, and integrity of personal information. These improved protections include developing and using reasonable steps to select and retain service providers capable of appropriately safeguarding consumer personal information. “Personal information” is defined in this context to include persistent identifiers such as cookies.
Continue Reading Mobile Phone Manufacturer Settles with FTC Over Allegations that Its Vendor Collected Personal Data without Consent

On January 2, 2018, the Standardization Administration of China (“SAC”) released the final version of the national standard on personal information protection, officially entitled GB/T 35273-2017 Information Technology – Personal Information Security Specification (GB/T 35273-2017 信息安全技术 个人信息安全规范) (hereinafter “the Standard”).  The Standard will come into effect on May 1, 2018.

As highlighted in our previous coverage of drafts of the Standard (see here and here), although it is nominally a voluntary framework, the Standard effectively sets out the best practices that will be expected by regulators auditing companies and enforcing China’s existing (but typically more generally-worded) data protection rules, most notably the 2016 Cybersecurity Law.  Drafts of the Standard — even prior its finalization — have also in some cases been the basis for non-compliance remediation plans and undertakings agreed between companies and the Cyberspace Administration of China (“CAC”) following CAC audits, as we reported here.

The Standard applies to “personal information controllers,” namely any private or public organization that has “the power to decide the purpose and method” of processing personal information.  This is seemingly modelled on European law’s “data controller” concept.

The Standard regulates the use of “personal information” by these controllers, a term largely aligned with strict conceptualizations of “personal data” under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (“GDPR”).  Examples of “personal information” listed in an annex to the Standard include device hardware serial codes, IP addresses, website tracking records, and unique device identifiers, among other things.  The definition of “sensitive personal information,” however, takes a different approach to the GDPR: rather than applying only to specific types of data, the Standard takes a risk-based approach, defining “sensitive” personal information as any personal information which, if lost or misused, is capable of endangering persons or property, easily harming personal reputation and mental and physical health, or leading to discriminatory treatment.  According to the Standard, this could for example include national identification card numbers, login credentials, banking and credit details, a person’s accurate location, information on a person’s real estate holdings, and information about a minor (under 14 years old).

Similar to general principles of most data protection laws, the Standard requires transparency, specificity and fairness of processing purpose, proportionality (use and retention of only the minimum information necessary to achieve the stated purpose), security, risk assessment, and the respect of individuals’ rights to control the processing of information about them.  It also requires either consent from individuals, or reliance on a limited range of exceptions set out in the Standard, for the purpose of collection and processing of personal information.

This article looks at some of these aspects in more detail, including some of their key divergences from European data protection law, including the GDPR.  (Please note that this is not an exhaustive description of the Standard, nor is it a detailed comparison with the GDPR.)
Continue Reading China Issues New Personal Information Protection Standard

Yan Luo advises clients on a broad array of regulatory matters in connection with cybersecurity and data protection rules in China. With previous work experience in Washington, DC and Brussels before relocating to Beijing, Yan has fostered her government and regulatory skills in all three capitals. She is able to strategically advise international companies on Chinese regulatory matters and represent Chinese companies in regulatory reviews in other markets.

Over the past two years, Yan has provided practical advice to clients on nearly all aspects of China’s Cybersecurity Law. She continues to help them navigate the complex and quickly evolving regulatory regime, including on issues arising out of personal information protection, cross border data transfers, and various cybersecurity requirements.

What provisions of China’s Cybersecurity Law have caused the greatest concern for U.S. companies? What advice do you have for these companies when it comes to compliance?
Continue Reading National Cybersecurity Awareness Month Q&A with Yan Luo

In the past three weeks, China’s State Council and the State Cryptography Administration (“SCA”) issued two documents that reveal a major change in the regulatory regime governing commercial encryption products in China, potentially paving the way for the draft Encryption Law to establish a uniformed encryption regime. This development and its practical implications will be important to multinationals that manufacture, distribute, or use commercial encryption products in China.

On September 29, 2017, the State Council released the Decision on Removing a Batch of Administrative Approval Requirements (the “State Council Decision”) (official Chinese version available here), which removed some approval requirements for the manufacturing, sale, and use of commercial encryption products. On October 12, 2017, the SCA further released a notice (“Notice”) to instruct local Bureaus of Cryptography Administration (“BCA”) on the plan to implement the State Council Decision.  (The official Chinese version can be found here.)

The State Council Decision and the Notice reveals a major change in the regulatory regime governing commercial encryption products in China, potentially paving the way for an Encryption Law that would establish a uniform encryption regime. (Our previous alert describing the draft Encryption Law can be found here.)
Continue Reading China Revises Proposals on Regulation of Commercial Encryption

On July 26, four Chinese agencies, the Cyberspace Administration of China (“CAC”), the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology (“MIIT”), the Ministry of Public Security (“MoPS”), and the National Standards Committee, announced their plan to begin the government’s campaign to improve the protection of personal information, according to Xinhua News Agency (link is in Chinese).  The campaign, called “Action Plan to Improve Personal Information Protection,” will start with the audit of privacy policies of the ten most popular online services in China.

Officials from CAC’s Cybersecurity Coordination Bureau indicated that the privacy policy audit is an important step to implement China’s new Cybersecurity Law, which took effect on June 1, 2017.  Through this process, the regulators will balance the protection of personal information with the use of data to improve services for Chinese users.

This development signals the government agencies’ increased focus on companies’ data protection practices.  Companies operating in China should consider reviewing their privacy policies and data practices in country to conform with legal requirements and best practices.
Continue Reading Chinese Agencies Announce Plan to Audit Privacy Policies of Ten Popular Online Services

Today, the Cyberspace Administration of China (“CAC”) released the final version of the Measures on the Security Review of Network Products and Services (Trial) (“the Measures”), with an effective date of June 1, 2017 (official Chinese version available here).  The issuance of the Measures marks a critical first step toward implementing China’s Cybersecurity Law (“the Law”), which was promulgated on November 7, 2016 and will take effect on June 1, 2017 (the same date as the Measures).

More specifically, the long-anticipated Measures offer guidance on how CAC is planning to conduct cybersecurity reviews of network products and services procured by entities in a range of key sectors and other operators of Critical Information Infrastructure (“CII”), if the procurement “may affect China’s national security.”

A draft form of the Measures was released in February 2017 for public comment (see Covington’s alert on the draft Measures here).  Since then, international stakeholders have been submitting comments to the CAC and changes in the final version reflect some of these comments.  The Measures, however, still lack clarity with respect to certain aspects of the review process, both in terms of substantive criteria and procedure.  Companies that may be subject to such reviews will likely need further guidance from the agencies once the Measures take effect.

This post identifies two key changes in the final version.
Continue Reading China Releases Final Regulation on Cybersecurity Review of Network Products and Services

On April 11, 2017, the Cyberspace Administration of China (“CAC”) released a draft of the Measures on Security Assessment of Cross-border Data Transfer of Personal Information and Important Data (“the Draft Measures”) for public comment (official Chinese version available here).  The comment period ends on May 11, 2017.

The issuance of the long-anticipated Draft Measures is another critical step toward implementing China’s Cybersecurity Law (“the Law”), which is set to take effect on June 1, 2017 (see our alert on the Law here).  Importantly, the Draft Measures, if enacted in its current form, would mandate all “network operators” to self-assess the security of their cross-border data transfers and significantly broaden the scope of entities that potentially need to undergo security assessments for such transfers by the Chinese government.  Companies that fall into the scope of “network operators,” but may not qualify for “operators of Critical Information Infrastructure” (“CII”), could see their cross-border data transfers regulated under the Draft Measures.  
Continue Reading China Seeks Public Comments on Draft Regulation on Cross-Border Data Transfer